
By BECKY KISER
Hays Post
Hays city commissioners heard a recommendation Thursday for renewal of city employee health insurance with Blue Cross Blue Shield of Kansas (BCBSKS) in 2027, despite the company's ongoing negotiations with the HaysMed.
The hospital announced this summer it was negotiating with BCBS for higher reimbursement rates. If it did not receive higher rates, it said it would terminate its contract with the insurer as of Dec. 31.
Erin Giebler, human resources director, said the BCBS renewal rate was one-half percent. Other proposals ranged from 39% to 58% increases in premiums.
"We did have to consider that HaysMed, one of our employees' top providers, may not be in-network next year. So we did feel it was necessary to go out for bids and see what other providers and options are out there," Giebler said.
"The lowest bid was from Blue Cross Blue Shield, and the next closest non-Blue Cross provider was $1.2 million above our renewal. That was with the Aetna self-insured plan."
Giebler noted the city's premium costs are well below the national average.
"A lot of that has to do with low employee utilization over the long run," she said.
The employee wage and benefit committee took the information to all employees who determined they preferred to stay with Blue Cross Blue Shield.
BCBS does allow employees to go to out-of-network providers but the billing process is different.
The provider bills the employee the full amount. The employee then files their claim with Blue Cross Blue Shield. The insurance company uses a different formula for processing out-of-network claims than for in-network claims.
Blue Cross pays the employee directly for their covered amount, not the provider. Then the employee is responsible for paying the bill to the provider.
It would be up to HaysMed's discretion whether they write anything off the bill.
Ultimately, it usually costs the employee more to go to an out-of-network provider, Giebler said.
Shaun Musil, commissioner, said if HaysMed does not renew with Blue Cross Blue Shield, it could have a huge effect on the community.
"People come here to go to the Hays hospital. They'll go somewhere else," Musil said.
Mason Ruder mayor, said he heard in a presentation from hospital representatives Thursday morning that "they're not even close to a negotiated agreement."
"It's important to note we're not the first community or the first hospital to be affected by this," said Alaina Cunningham, vice-mayor, said, "and we're not the first health facility to fight to be appropriately reimbursed. It's going to affect our community, and it's going to hurt individuals, but there's a lot more pieces to it than just that."
SEE RELATED STORIES:
BCBS, HaysMed continue negotiations; Q&A with hospital, insurer
Local patients grapple with possibility of losing HaysMed as in-network provider
Medicare and Medicaid patients are not affected by the negotiations.
Short-term disability
Giebler also recommended a change in short-term disability providers. USAlliance submitted a proposal that is less than the current provider’s rate.
The city has used Aetna/Hartford as its provider since 2014, with the short-term disability insurance rate remaining at $0.33 per $10 of covered payroll.
The USAlliance bid was lower at $0.265 per $10 of covered payroll.
Commissioners moved the recommendations on to their next meeting, Tuesday, Nov. 24.

Bickle-Schmidt Sports Complex
Jeff Boyle, parks director, recommended bids for a new shade structure and for replacement playground surfacing in the northeast quad of the sports complex.
Staff recommended replacing the current fabric-topped structure, installed in 2011, with a wood or metal-framed structure, which holds up much better, as seen with the structure on the southwest quad which was replaced after a windstorm in 2018.
Boyle recommended the sole bid from Leitner Buildings, Hays, in the amount of $99,990. An amount of $160,000 is budgeted in the Special Park and Recreation budget for the structure plus Pour-in-Play playground surfacing.
The playground surfacing was installed in 2011 and was subject to blowing infield dirt throughout most of its life, causing it to deteriorate faster than normal.
The low bid from Ecoturf Surfacing is less than the budget at $54,238.
Commissioners moved the recommendations on to their meeting on Tuesday.
E-bike and motor scooters
During comments, commissioners talked of their concerns about children riding E-bikes and electric motor scooters in a dangerous manner on city streets.
They agreed they're not currently interested in any sort of city ordinance limiting young riders and the onus is on parents to educate their children about traffic rules and safety gear.
Cunningham suggested the Hays Police Department bring back a rewards program for children seen riding defensively and obeying traffic laws.
She recalled her own children being stopped and given a free Cerv's Snoball certificate by officers about 10 years ago.
"Positive reinforcement works for kids," Cunningham said.
David Vilaysing, commissioner, and a retired Hays police officer, said passing a new ordinance won't help.
"We need to enforce [existing traffic ordinance] violations," he said. "As appropriate, the parents should be ticketed."






