Nov 25, 2019 8:19 PM

Judge: Religious exemption form for vaccines constitutional

Posted Nov 25, 2019 8:19 PM



Kansas News Service

A federal judge has rejected a Kansas City charter school student's claim that Missouri's official religious exemption form for vaccines is an unconstitutional infringement of religious freedom. 

The child, identified as W.B., and his parents, Zach and Audrey Baker, sued the Crossroads Academy and Missouri’s health agency, the Department of Health and Senior Services, over the language in the official form.

The Bakers objected to wording encouraging parents to immunize their children. But Senior U.S. District Judge Howard Sachs rejected their argument that by requiring them to sign the form, the state was engaging in “compelled speech.”

“The State’s freedom to advocate vaccination as governmental policy is also well settled,” Sachs wrote in a 10-page ruling Friday denying the Bakers’ request for a preliminary injunction. “The official form containing modest advocacy is divided into parts which separate the advocacy language by the State from the wording to be used by a parent claiming an exemption. It thus passes muster as constitutionally acceptable.”

Missouri law requires students to be immunized, subject to exemptions based on “religious beliefs or medical contraindications.” All 50 states and the District of Columbia have laws requiring specified vaccines, and all of them grant exemptions for medical reasons. Forty-five states and Washington, D.C., grant religious exemptions and 15 states also allow philosophical objections.

Sachs noted that the Bakers could still fill out an official exemption form to exempt their child from vaccination. Any harm resulting from W.B.’s suspension from school, he wrote, would be the parents’ fault.

Sachs deferred his ruling until Dec. 16 to give the Bakers a chance to secure an exemption for W.B. if they wish.

W.B.’s grandfather, Stilwell, Kansas, attorney Linus Baker, represents the family in the lawsuit, as well as three other families.

He also represents another grandchild, whom he has since adopted, in a similar case in federal court in Kansas. That case is pending.

Reached for comment on Sachs’ decision, Baker said that he disagreed with the ruling.

“He (Sachs) clearly said that (the Department of Health and Senior Services) was targeting these parents and trying to convince them of the government’s message, in contradiction of their religious beliefs,” Baker said. “He said they don’t have to be neutral.”

An overwhelming number of studies have demonstrated the safety and effectiveness of vaccines in saving lives and preventing disease.

Dan Margolies is a senior reporter and editor at KCUR. You can reach him on Twitter @DanMargolies.

Continue Reading Hays Post
Nov 25, 2019 8:19 PM
Flipp interactive online circulars available on Hays Post!

Hays Post has partnered with Flipp to offer interactive online circulars! Check this week’s bargains out here! Don’t see the circular you want in the preview? Click on an ad to pull up a search menu for retailers like Dillons, Walmart, JCPenney and so much more!

If you are having problems loading the circulars, please check your ad blocker settings.

All of your weekly ads in one place.

Say goodbye to your paper ads! Flipp delivers digital ads from more than 1,000 retailers so you can find the best deals in your area every week.

Discover offers by browsing through the weekly ads from retailers you love, or by searching for the items you need.

Flipp takes the “extreme” out of Extreme Couponing.

Flipp has coupons from the top brands and retailers that will help you save 20% to 70% on a wide variety of products.

Find coupons and use them in store!

Plan your shopping trips and maximize your savings with the ultimate shopping list

Easily create a shopping list by adding items from weekly ads or adding in your own. Find the best deals on your products and easily save you shopping list and share it with a loved one. Print the list or loads it on your Flipp app and have it available on the go!

Click HERE to view the circulars. And you can always find the latest circulars between the News and Sports sections on!